Image for post
Image for post
Image credit: Mikepaws

All there is

“None so blind as those who will not see”

At the end of last year, Britain’s Royal Statistical Society invited, for the first time, their members and the general public to nominate their favourite statistic. In the world of words, dictionaries like the OED and Merriam-Webster have had a word of the year tradition for over 10 years now. Germany’s national language society, the GfDS, has even been choosing a Wort des Jahres since 1971. It was obviously time for a numerical equivalent.

The UK statistic of the year referred to the percentage of UK land area that is ‘densely built upon’, also known as continuous urban fabric. If you’ve not heard of the statistic, even if you’ve not been to the UK, do take a guess (the answer is somewhere further in this article.)

Not so educated guesses

Such educated guesses are an intriguing combination of facts and beliefs, and so in a sense they are a collaboration between Daniel Kahneman’s two thinking systems. The fast and impulsive System 1 is quick to tap into our feelings and impressions, and the slow, logical System 2 takes its time to reason and consider. But sometimes there is not a lot of reasoning, and the process is dominated by heuristics and beliefs, without us realizing that’s what happens. In the UK, 83% lives in cities and conurbations, and of those who don’t, many more work in them. Built-up areas are salient in our experience. We do visit the countryside, of course, and we may occasionally even see the country from the air and be surprised by how small cities are and how much open space there is in between. But the dominant visual picture for most people is one of bricks and concrete, roads and buildings, and that ‘educates’ our guess more than any reasoning we might be doing.

Kahneman calls this WYSIATI — “What You See Is All There Is”. This describes our tendency to be influenced most strongly by our “known knowns”, and is linked to several cognitive biases. One of these is the availability heuristic, the mental shortcut that activates the concepts that are most easily brought to mind. For example, when we think of a swan, most of us would imagine a white one, simply because that is the only colour of swan most of us see. A related one is base rate neglect, which can make us believe in the power of faith healing or other interventions that lack any scientific basis. If we don’t realize how likely it is that a particular condition improves without any intervention, it is tempting to believe that such an improvement is the result of prayer, hand waving or sugar pills. Confirmation bias reinforces the WYSIATI-effect, because it makes us see (and indeed look for) what we already know to be the case. And the overconfidence bias makes us excessively confident of the perception that what we see is indeed all there is. (By the way, the percentage of densely built upon ‘continuous urban fabric’ in the UK is 0.13%, that is just 320 square kilometres. Were you close? The map below shows both continuous and discontinuous urban fabric in red — the actual continuous part is less than 1/50 of all the red colour.)

Image for post
Image for post
More open space than you thought — source: A Land Cover Atlas of the United Kingdom

Perilous perceptions

In the most recent one, the subjects had to say in which countries they thought people consume the most alcohol. Russia came out top (it is actually only in 7th position). This is not so much because we see drunken Russians everywhere, but more likely because it is received (and unverified) wisdom. Only 4% of respondents put the real leader in alcohol consumption (Belgium) in their top 3. Even in Belgium, just 5% of respondents correctly guessed they are citizens of the world’s booziest country.

The Perils of Perception polls are full of this kind of sometimes spectacular misperceptions. The figure below shows some intriguing highlights where people get it wrong by considerable margins, often by a more than an order of magnitude.

Image for post
Image for post
(source: The Perils of Perception 2016 and 2017)

(A note of caution: I have obviously been selective in picking the examples to support my cause here. What you see here is not all there is!)

Rushing to a conclusion

The pernicious nature of WYSIATI is precisely that we don’t reason. This old riddle illustrates how easily we jump to conclusions: a father and his son are in a horrible car crash that kills the dad. The son is rushed to the hospital. Just as he is about to go under the knife, the surgeon exclaims, “I can’t operate — that boy is my son!” How can this be?

Just like we assume swans are white because that is what we mostly see, we think surgeons are men because most surgeons we know (about) are men. Did you, for a moment there, fail to realize that the surgeon was the boy’s mother? WYSIATI makes us unwittingly biased and reinforces stereotyping.

Of course we can never see everything, and there will always be stuff that is outside our immediate field of vision, that we don’t remember, or that is at odds with our received wisdom. But what we can do is remind ourselves of our limited perspective on the world around us — especially when we feel particularly confident about our judgement.

If we’re aware that what we see is not all there is, we already see a little more.

Originally published at koenfucius.wordpress.com on February 22, 2018.

Thank you for reading this post. If you enjoyed it, please click or tap the 👏 ‘clapping hands’ icon somewhere nearby. It’s nice to know it’s being appreciated, and your applause makes it easier for other people to discover the post. And do please share it with the world — Twitter and Facebook buttons on this page do the hard work for you, but don’t hesitate to use other platforms of your choice. Thank you!

Written by

Accidental behavioural economist in search of wisdom. Uses insights from (behavioural) economics in organization development. On Twitter as @koenfucius

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store